Mystery Trackers: Black Isle Collector's Edition
I usually love this series, but I was disappointed by this one.
I thought the story was really boring, so lost what I was trying to achieve as I keep losing interest in the game. Some of the HO scene were blurry. A lot of the other puzzle games were to simple, and mostly I have seen them elsewhere. In general it was a very basic game and I would only recommend to beginners.
March 26, 2012
While I did enjoy playing this game at first, I did not think it the calibre of the first two MT games; graphics were great, but I actually liked Raincliff the best, for level of challenge, graphics, story, that one blew me away!
Played the free and trial and bought this as soon as it came out, but I became more and more disappointed that this was not the usual outstanding MT game. The story just didn't grab me like the first two in the series. It actually got boring after a while; most of the HOS were simple to the point of making me feel like a dolt.
There is way too much running back and forth, and I guess that's why they put the map in that lets you transport from one location to the next - I hate running back and forth!
I do like collecting morphing objects and when I realized there were owls hidden in the HOS, well that did add a little to the game. Not the level of Raincliff for creepy or spooky; wasn't anything really startling in this game, and I've come to expect that from the MT games.
I have to say I agree with everything Ella_2011 said about this game, and I am actually surprised at the number of "expert" players that gave this game 5 stars.
The best thing about this game is the little dog you "rescue", if it hadn't been for my little companion keeping me company, I would have gotten a serious whack upside the head when it hit the computer keyboard from boredom.
The game almost feels like it was just thrown together, however, I did like the bonus game.
I do not recommend buying the CE, but SE is probably worth it.
April 2, 2012
This game was just so-so, in my opinion. The things I didn't like about it were:
Usage of Inventory items was not always logical or apparent.
Too much back-and-forthing to get and use Inventory items.
Way too many Hidden Object Scenes. These are often triggered by use of an Inventory item and become a tiresome pattern.
Hidden Object scenes are not clear and seemed junkish.
Mini-games are either very easy or very difficult.
The Hint button gives away too much information. I'd rather just be pointed in the right direction, not told exactly where to go and what to do.
Nothing about it was "fun".
The storyline didn't grab me.
March 24, 2012
Great Plot Twist Goes Missing in Action
I finally figured out when a SG comes in really handy. When I am so bored, that I cannot remember where I have been, what I have been doing, and what I am supposed to be doing next.
MT: BI is a redemption/ love story. It could have worked and should have, but it failed to inspire much empathy in me. It has all the bells and whistles available to produce a great game, but somewhere along the way, I became less and less engaged. I should have been tipped off by the beginning with its endless back and forth between The Cafe and The Shop.
Maybe as lovely as the graphics are, they did not entrance me in anyway. Maybe the music is wrong and became annoying. Maybe the puzzle execution felt stale and grew to be tiresome. This is three "maybe's" in a row. What I do know is that I began to feel sorry for Conrad. This MT Investigator kept making all sorts of stupid suppositions and killed The Theme.
I liked Elf. I liked Elf even better when he reappears in the bonus chapters wearing an official MTI "badge".
Maybe you will enjoy MT: BI. Maybe you won't. I think, maybe, it depends on what you think a good game is for you.
March 24, 2012
Just did not like the feel of it.
Already had the previous 2 games in this series so was looking forward to this one, wrong. Although this game game is similar to them (and to most HOGs) there is something about the overall feel of this one that just makes me say "pass".
March 2, 2012
Played through the demo, and liked it enough to probably buy the game.
- gameplay overall
- storyline is okay
- too much achievements, you can't concentrate on the actual gameplay when you're thinking all the time about the achievements. Also some of them were really difficult! This takes one star away from my rating.
- once again, sooo much like MCF! Compare this to Dire Grove for example. It's good because MCF's last game was a letdown, bad because it's too alike MCF. It takes away one more star anyhoo.
Enjoyable, but not enough since the achievements are constantly on your mind.
March 11, 2012
I was excited when I saw a new Mystery Trackers game. Have the other 2 and they are excellent. This one however falls short of the mark somehow. Graphics and sound are still excellent but I found some of the games very frustrating. I enjoy a challenge and always play games on expert or hardcore if available and never skip a game. The mini games here are either very easy or just too hard, I mean 45 moves to solve a tile game, give me a break. Had to resort to the strategy guide. Loved the little dog character but just didn't enjoy this game as much as the other 2.
If you haven't played the other 2 you would probably enjoy this, it is a good length but wait for the SE.
March 4, 2012
Much Better Gameplay than Raincliff
I might have Enjoyed this game more
IF the story was interesting
Raincliff was a Great Story but Horrible Gameplay
This game is Much Improved Gameplay
with a Rather Dull story...
In this game
There is a map which will transport you
and it seemed to be there was not as far to go
or as much running around as there was in Raincliff
I do like the mini games in this series..
The majority are not that challanging
yet all are entertaining..
The Bonus Gameplay was Generous
However it isnt necessary to the story...
I would have been completely satisfied
by using a free game credit on the SE Instead..
All in all i can Recommend this game..
May 24, 2013
MET MYSELF COMING AND GOING
I played this entire game plus the bonus chapter in the advanced mode. There is a map and the map lets you change locations by clicking on it. The map legend showed icons for blocked areas, current location, and areas that needed action. There were 3 primary areas on the map. Once you left an area, the map no longer accurately showed areas that needed action, even though, throughout the game, you had to retrace you steps back to the earlier locations. This was very disappointing and led to my frustration with the game. By the time I got to the bonus chapter, I was just wishing it would end.
Towards the end, the running around was particularly bad. I got so tired of it, that I didn't even try to figure out where to go next. I just hit the hint button and let it tell me. The hint button was excellent, thankfully, and gave a detailed description of where and what the next action should be.
The HOS were good; some tougher than others. Same with the mini games; some were easy and some I had to skip. The ability to earn achievement awards was a nice addition. I missed getting all the owls by one, even though I clicked on the last one, but it didn't recognize it.
Entirely too much back and forth for me to enjoy the game.
December 19, 2012
Not Up To Par For Mystery Trackers
Not necessarily a bad game but not as good as is usual for MT. First 3/4 of game takes place in the same area over and over and over. It finally opens up to additional areas but it's definitely not as challenging or interesting, as their other games.
April 13, 2012