Dark Tales: Edgar Allan Poe's The Gold Bug
Waited for the SE and can't see how another chapter of the same would rate as a CE. Everything about this game was just OK. Artwork a little lifeless and drab for ERS; scenes were heavy on the pirates and everything was big and lacking in detail ; vos were bland, though able to click through character text dialog; music was uninspiring; story predictable; HOs were interactive silhouette type; puzzles fun, but not challenging; and the dog was not necessary to the play. This game is just OK, nothing more.
February 23, 2013
Sorry about this review, but I was really looking forward to playing another of the Dark Tale games. Pros: Graphics-Cons: everything else. I only played the demo but I was bored to tears. Nothing new except a cute dog. I really feel let down by the developers of this game. Gamers are a little more savvy than you give them credit. There were expectations that just weren't met with this new game. Why bother spending more money just play one of the older games in the series. I gurantee you will enjoy it more and it won't cost you a penny. I definetly would not recommend buying this game.
February 9, 2013
Very disappointed with this one
Dark Tales: Edgar Allan Poe's... The Black Cat; Premature Burial... those were decent games, & i was looking for similar quality here, fully expecting to enjoy another jaunt with Dupin and solve another engrossing mystery. I gotta be honest: i couldn't make myself finish this game which, for me, just doesn't make the cut. Cartoonish, washed out graphics, over-simplistic and under-developed storyline, and gameplay that was so bloody boring i had to bid Adieu to Dupin, possibly forever, sigh. There was essentially no challenge to the play - move there, pick up that, put it there, over & over, without building on this extremely simplified storyline... the entire content seemed to be made to appeal to young first timers - which is fine i suppose, but I expected a better experience with the name of Poe attached to the game, after having so enjoyed previous installments in the series. This game just felt like a rush job, not well executed, and yeah, painfully boring. Maybe i expect some growth in a game series... progress, enhancements in art, story, gameplay, etc. But imo this dev doesn't deliver at all on this one, & even for gamers who are new to the venue, there are lots of games out there that are so much better than this. You can sniff 'em out. This one smells like failure. Sorry, but i would not recommend this game.
March 7, 2013
people, can we please demand more challenging games? these are no longer interactive puzzle games. They are like the daily word search puzzles to occupy the mundane waiting for a bus. Zero challenge and disheartening to see the masses drinking the mediocrity Kool-Aid. read a book.
February 9, 2013
i played about 30 minutes of the demo, backed out and deleted.
sorry, ERS, but this is a no-buy for me. i have played all of the puppetshow games, all of the redemption cemetery games as well as all the rest of your "series"-type games and i am now officially tired of the formula. many of these games have the same music, same artwork, even the same FONT! can't you change things up a little?
actually, you can. make another game like "dark alleys: penumbra motel" and you might tempt me. might.
my other complaint is the linear quality of the games. you can go to three scenes at a time, basically, and when you're done, you move onto the next group of three scenes. i like the non-linear games better because there is more challenge to remember where you need to use an inventory item.
all in all, this game was just TOO EASY. i like some *challenge* to the games i buy! i played this one on the hardest mode of the three (no hints, no black bar tips... let alone the hated *sparkles*!) and STILL it was easy. the puzzles i encountered, i didn't even really have to think about how to do them because i've seen them so many times before.
please, ERS, *challenge me*! when you do, i will start buying your games again! and yes, i WILL demo your games to see what you're offering, but if there's no challenge, even on the hardest mode, there's no buy from this fishie.
February 17, 2013
This was one of the worst games I have played in a while. There was absolutely no challenge to anything. I am very happy I only played the demo.
March 2, 2013
My game was full of errors. I didnt like this game a lot
February 22, 2013
Dirty trick! The old bait and switch.
The demo was very nice - had some neat puzzles, "use an item to get an item" H0's, a few clever inventory uses and the promise of hunting pirate treasure. I wasn't quite intrigued enough to buy the CE but looked forward to purchasing this SE.
What a let down! Once the demo chapters are over, this game is nothing but back-to-back standard H0's, back-to-basics puzzles and tedious back-tracking. Speaking of back, that's how I want my money. The devs polished up the first chapters, promising a decent game, and then tossed the rest together with leftover bits from all of their last year's games. "Play the demo, see if you like it!" would be very, very bad advice.
I tried to give it a chance, hoping that later chapters wold be better but after an hour I was just too bored to go any further.
I'll be very careful to read all the reviews of an Ers game from now on.
February 8, 2013
Well, almost immediately I started to hate this game, and by the time I'd played 30 minutes of the demo, I was thoroughly irritated and bored.
1. I hate looking for silhouettes.
2. I didn't like the progressive HOS.
3. I especially didn't like looking for silhouettes in a progressive HOS.
4. The gimmick of having the dog look for things was... erm... a little bit cute, but irritating to have to notice if an item had a paw print or not.
5. I kept missing the hint button and clicking on the dog by mistake.
6. A brightly-colored, childish, puppet-boat game as a puzzle to open a lock?? Whaaa???? The gate is old and rickety, but the lock looks like a brand new, hand-drawn puppet show? Looks like it's drawn out of a children's coloring book. Stupid.
7. Finding the wave to go with the puppet show was another silhouetted HO.
Finding a game you like is a personal thing, so try it. If nothing else, Dupin is verrry easy on the eyes.
July 3, 2013
Very disappointed - played a previous Edgar Allen Poe game but this was just all over the place and really not interested in continuing
March 10, 2013