Dark Dimensions: City of Ash Collector's Edition
Worth Playing, Enjoyed the Demo.
It seems this developer just can?t wow me- They can make some good games sure, but not one of those thrillers than makes me want to buy it and complete the game. I did enjoy the demo, but not once did I consider buying.
The problem I had with the first two games was that I didn?t know what my purpose was. This game was different as I knew what my purpose was from the start. The storyline was a little different, and I enjoyed it, but it didn?t suck me in. The storyline is very similar to the Mount Vesuvius disaster in Pompeii, so historians might enjoy this.
The story takes a great turn towards the end of the demo, and I was really starting to like this evil character.
I couldn?t help but notice how stupid some parts of this game were. For example, I picked up a valve and used it on something, then got it back to use something else. That never happens in other games, and I doubt it would happen in real-life.
Also, during one of the HOS, one of my interactive items was pizza. You had to put pepperoni on the pizza to make it a complete object (stupid already- since when is pizza a Hidden Object) but to add to the stupidity, the ?pizza? was just rolled out dough. HAHAHAHAHAHA! I was spending all this time trying to find an actual pizza, only to discover that it was rolled out dough.
While I?m on the subject of HOS, they appeared frequently, not too much, just frequent. I liked them, as they were a good challenge for me and included a number of extra step objects (one of which required two steps), so, kudos to the developer for the challenge there.
The puzzles were a little different though. 2 of them were foolishly easy, (the coin one and the triangle one) and others were a little hard. Lucky for me, I had a Strategy Guide and quick recharging hint and my disposal. I must admit, the math one stumped me!
The graphics were much improved from the first two games. The artwork was clear and well done, with the HOS being exceptionally clear. These graphics were outstanding. I can?t really fault the developer on those.
The voice-overs were standard. The acting was standard, not over-done, which was good. The voice-overs were a good fit for this game.
- Hint and Skip- fast recharge. Hint is very helpful
- 3 modes of difficulty- Casual, Advanced and Hard (I played casual)
- Diary to keep track of events. Can flip between past and present, also contains spoilers for the other two games
- Map, which is interactive and saves time backtracking.
- Built in Strategy Guide (CE Exclusive)- This was great for solving puzzles.
- There are Collections but there is no mention of what they are or how to get them
- Bonus Chapter (Bonus Content, CE Exclusive)
- Concept Art (Bonus Content, CE Exclusive)
- Music (Bonus Content, CE Exclusive)
- Wallpapers (Bonus Content, CE Exclusive)
While this game has some great CE Extras, the game itself is not gripping. While I enjoyed the demo, I don?t think I will be buying this game. That being said, I?m happy to recommend it.
June 8, 2013
Predictable, save length.
When you get an hour demo you expect to get that hour or at least a majority of it. Not twenty-five minutes. The puzzles were okay, but they seemed rushed, like they spent more time adding many puzzles in instead of making decent ones. Quantity of quality.
Unfortunately, again, this doesn't go for the length. When the length of the demo isn't even half of the time given, you start to realize that the chances are the game is relatively short.
The movement was stiff, and that's saying a lot for a point and click. The scenery was quite bland and every scene began to resemble the previous one.
The concept seems okay at first. A mining town led by a mayor who wants to continue mining even with the danger and the protests of his daughter is destroyed in a sudden and horrible event. You have to go back and free the trapped spirits from the same darkness that overtook the mayor.
This is where the real problems set in. Let us forget that this is the tenth town I've seen this month overtaken by something dark. Being led by a ghost girl, now a staple in nearly every game, has turned this game from somewhat original content to barely different. i also must point out the many times she'll try to talk or throw something to you and the 'dark antagonist' will stop her. This would be an impacting moment if it didn't happen every five minutes; and I certainly counted, because there was only twenty-five.
Cliches aside, the story wasn't very captivating. I have this feeling that this game was very rushed. This game has many, many similarities to the game Shiver: The Vanishing Hitchhiker. Following the girl, dark spirits, abandoned town from horrific event; the big difference is that it is obvious that Shiver tried to make it different.
I'd make a pass. However, if you do purchase the game and don't enjoy it, then don't worry. It will be over very quickly.
June 7, 2013
Review of Game
This is the 3rd game in the Dark Dimensions series. We had fog, then wax, now ash. Game ran fine. HOS are ok-no misclick penalty and some variations. Puzzles were poorly described as far as directions. Music and VO were fine. Picture was kind of grainy-- I guess you'd call it. Wasn't sure if they were going for the ashy look :) The cursor always seemed a bit "off". Had a wide pixel area. You are set out to save the town that was turned to ash. Sadly, this turns out to be quite easy. The game has absolutely NO challenge at all. You find a hammer next to you, use the hammer in front of you, etc etc. There is a jump map which is small but fast. You also have a journal. The hint recharges quickly, although you probably won't need it. I've read reviews of the completed game. With the CE, the game totals 3.5 hours. So NOT CE material developers !!!!! Even as an SE, NO. I'm passing on this one due to the simplistic nature of the game and and length. A beginner could play this game and think it were easy.
June 1, 2013
The Game Was Alight, Not The Ending
The game itself was alright, but the ending left me hanging, both in the game and in the bonus. Layout of games was somewhat confusing, but once I caught the jest of where we were going with them, I learned to look elsewhere for answers. I was somewhat lulled to sleep with some of the game as the action so typical of BF games was lacking. For me, I would recommend this game to a beginner, but the more seasoned player may wish to have more depth to the game. Graphics were alright, but I would not call them outstanding. The story was good, but lacked continuity.
June 6, 2013
Disappointing, but recommended for beginners!
Okay, I have the first two DD games (City of Fog is the best) and was a little disappointed in this one. Graphics were okay, although a little washed out. Game play is nice, SG is nice, music and sound FX good. Hint system seemed a little slow on the return, but helpful when used. Very nice voice overs. Nice jump map (I like the way it is set up).
There is a lot of talking, maybe to make the game seem longer than it is. I don't care for games that do not show you all the chapters in a demo, they are usually always short games and I won't pay that much for one. I do not like it when I click off the custom cursor and it doesn't return to the arrow...very irritating...why bother putting that option in the settings when it is useless.
HOGs are a mix of straight HOG and "find me and use me with another item." Games are very simple. I did not find this game challenging at all and got bored with it very quickly. Don't know what the deal is lately, but we have had a rash of very poor games. This is not a bad game, but did not grab me and make me want to buy it to see what happens. I recommend this game as more of a beginner level. Not for me.
As always, try it for yourself and see what you think. We all have different tastes in games and you may find this one to your liking. Thanks for the reviews.
June 1, 2013
One big yawn...
I've enjoyed the games in this series, but this one is a lame duck. Way too many HOS..one after the other after the other, and not very inspiring.
Too much hand holding, and far too linear. The map was pretty useless; wonder why they bothered with it at all.
Very disappointing. `Be okay for beginners maybe.
June 1, 2013
I'm Afraid Another No Go For A Collector's Edition - Review Based On Demo
HOPA (Hidden Object Puzzle Adventure)
Story: The townspeople of Phoenix Hill, a mining community, have all turned to ash after an apparent volcanic eruption so of course you have to help the townspeople rise from the ashes.
Chapters: Only shows the first 2 in the strategy guide so not sure how many there are.
3 play modes: Casual, Advanced Hard. I played Advance mode but checked out the 2 other modes of play. There is black bar info for all, no hints or skips in hardest, sparkles only in casual .
Collectibles in main and bonus game -- perhaps well hidden, I only came across 1 in the demo, then again there are only 15.
Widescreen: This did fill my 20 inch monitor however graphics do appear to be a bit stretched.
Map: You get shortly into the game and has 28 locations and they unlock as you move forward in the game. It is also transporter, has all the names of the locations, and shows where you are but doesn't state if there is anything to do or not.
HOS: All found by word list and are interactive (an extra step involved to complete some of them).
Puzzles: The usual run of the mill found in many games. I came across nothing really new here. They do have an info button to get more info on how to complete them if needed.
Hint/Skip: Very slow on charge up for advance mode. Hint is helpful outside of HOS. You don't have to wait for it to charge up outside of HOS but you do have to keep pressing the hint until it takes you were you need to be.
Strategy Guide: Not bookmarked but well executed.
The usual fluff such as wallpapers
My overall impression:
I'm sorry but this just didn't grab my attention. This game just didn't WOW me.
The graphics for some areas for me were crisp and clear while some other areas a couple of the HOS scenes appear to be drab/washed out. The HOS a little on the Sanford & Son junkyard but not too bad some scenes. Graphics also appeared to be stretched as I mentioned.
The puzzles I came across were very easy as I didn't need to skip them.
The story line is good but not gripping for me. The characters and voice overs OK along with the music as I found neither annoying but nothing that really stands out.
There's just nothing extra for me that I can justify paying $13.99 for. A smile and wink to the Big Fish and developer here: Finding 15 collectibles which are also found in the main game, wallpapers which I will admit to using some wallpapers but not a must have for me and the other fluff I don't use sorry but doesn't cut it. Truth be told I won't even buy the SE version when that gets released. I appreciate the effort by the developer here however just no WOW here for me that I must buy this game. CE or SE version.
Overall the best I can do for this is 3 stars. Sorry Big Fish and developer but I'm afraid this is a no go for me.
As always, give it a whirl and decide for yourself.
June 1, 2013
Disappointed in Third Installment
I was really looking forward to this game. I enjoyed the first two in the series, but this one is something of a disappointment. The game was short and the bonus chapter was not really worth the price of a CE. There were lots of iHOS (which I usually enjoy), but some of the interactive parts were confusing. The mini games were fairly good, but some of the instructions were too minimal. There were some "potion" making mini games which I really enjoy. The achievements revolved around finding "golden" animals that ended up looking like stone statues.
The interactive map was a nice feature and worked well. There were lots of locations to visit, but the story wasn't engaging enough to hold my interest. There is a built in SG which is always nice. The voice overs and graphics were well done. I muted the music (which I do with almost every game).
I really wanted to like this game, but it just didn't capture my imagination. I would not spend the money for the CE, but might consider the SE. The ending of the main game is satisfying and there is no need for the bonus chapter.
I hope the developers will go do a better job if there is a fourth installment.
If you are looking for a short game with nice graphics, I recommend the SE version of this game. Do not spend the money for the CE version.
July 14, 2013
dark dimensions: city of ash collectors edition
Lead in is too long, Even after playing when you go in you have to sit through the ashes, volcano and city on fire. too much. Other games once you play, its quicker to get into the actual game.
June 11, 2013
Sorry developers, but you've really let your fans down with this one.
I have loved their previous games, but this was appalling.
Good was the art work and a jumpable map is always welcomed, but that was all.
The story was very weak, the puzzle level was kindergarden, some of the items to use were senseless,
I have played SE games with more of a story and puzzle challenge than this game has.
I hope the developers read these comments too, as I 'm not the only bitterly disappointed fishie in the pond.
June 6, 2013