Echoes of the Past: The Kingdom of Despair Collector's Edition
a near miss
I almost didn't buy this game.
I had gotten bored by the similarity of the second and third of the series and wasn't even going to demo this.
I am glad I changed my mind though. The Devs have really put some thought into this and I found this newly revamped version to be quite a great time.
I think this has one of the best interactive maps I have seen in a game yet, and wish more Devs would do something like this. It was very easy to see what areas I should not bother with, and which areas I had something to do in, right away.
The graphics were rich and the worlds were believable and I thought the games appropriately difficult.
What I did not like was the painterly style on the Hidden Object Scenes....It was very hard to make out what was what, even though they were great paintings....and they were tough...almost unreasonably tough, by hiding most of an item underneath or behind something so that there was the barest clue there was something to select.
But, on the whole, bravo! and thank you for an entertaining time!
September 19, 2013
Not as good as the other 4!
Hello pond pals. Another Echoes game. I have the other 4 and really liked them all. I'm on the fence about this one. The graphics and game play are very nice. Games not easy and do take some thought and time to complete (so far#. HOGs are very simple, but fun...clean and clear so no eye strain. As usual, I do not care for the fact that you don't know how many chapters there are in the game, so can't judge approximate length of game either.
Voice overs make a game, but they could have been done a little better. They boy sounded very whinny and annoying. I like the locking inventory bar #can't stand for it to constantly pop up and down when I play). SG is nice and simple, but definitely in the wrong place. Too close to the hint bar and easy to hit the wrong button. Hint fills farily quickly, but has an annoying blink every few minutes or so. Didn't care for that at all.
There is a jump map, which you will constantly use, but a disappointment. Yes, it takes you where you want to go, but none of the locations are identified. A green dot does blink bright on the areas that have something to complete, but unless you have a very good memory, you are looking all over to find the room you need. Not much in the way of collectables either, or at least, not in the first chapter.
It was a nice game, but something seems to be missing...not sure what. I will probably purchase this game to add to my Echoes collection, but for now, it is going in my puddle for another day. Maybe when there is a special, but not today.
As always, try it for yourself and see what you think. We all have different tastes in games and you may find that this is exactly what you wanted today. Thanks for the reviews.
August 16, 2013
Gameplay is Great! Story, Not So Much...
Needing something new to try, I was delighted when I saw the new Echoes of the Past game. I was quick to download and try, and I was pretty impressed by the demo. I am considering buying (but I will wait for the SE).
The story is?. Well, it?s good, but not great, you know what I mean? I mean, it starts off great and the demo ends quite well, but everything in between there is not the best. The only things that happened were helping a blind boy, giving the queen back her heart (sounds quite like the Wizard of Oz, don?t you think?) and unlocking the next room and defeating the guard. The demo ends there. Again, not the best, and there probably should have been some more interesting things going on in the demo, but the gameplay was the winner for me.
It is quite often that I will buy a game not for the story, but for the gameplay. This would be one of those games. I actually had a lot of fun in the game. There was a great mixture of HOS and puzzles, and each HOS was a bit of challenge. The HOS are the classic junkpile ones, with one or two being ?place the item back in the scene? ones. Both of these I really enjoyed. The puzzles were a little bit hard for me, so I skipped them all. There was one exception, the feather one. I enjoyed this one even though I could not complete it. The strategy guide contains details on how to solve the puzzle, for those who get stuck.
For those wondering, the gameplay is not difficult. I was able to navigate my way around the scenes with no trouble at all. One problem I had though, was that I would sometimes get confused with the amount of rooms and accidently go in the wrong one. This did not trouble me though as I enjoyed the game.
The graphics are pretty good. I can make no complaints on these. The character designs and HO scenes are done pretty well, and each scene is good. However, these graphics are not great, and could have done with a little more work.
The voice-overs are standard. Again, good, but not great. The one positive is that the voice-overs aren?t over-done.
One issue I had with the visual/sound part of the game is the music. I kept hearing this annoying thump. Every 30-60 seconds or so, this thump would play. It annoyed me so much I had to turn the music/sound off.
- 3 modes of play: Casual, Advanced and Expert (at least I think that?s what they?re called). I played Casual. Last mode does not give you any hints.
- Hint and Skip recharge fairly quickly on Casual. Skip takes a little longer to recharge than the hint does. The hint is extremely useful outside HOS.
- Diary to keep track of events. I did not use it often.
- Interactive map. Areas where a task needs to be completed are highlighted in green. Areas completed are highlighted in white.
- Strategy Guide
- Bonus Chapter
- Concept Art
- The usual CE Extras
So, overall I was impressed by this game. The CE gets a four as there are no CE Extras that I feel the need to have. I will be buying the SE.
August 16, 2013
Not as Good as Others in Series
I did enjoy this game, I played it right through to the end and into the bonus, but I have to say it was getting a little boring and I had to force myself to finish it. That said, it was fun although it might have been more cost effective to buy the standard edition as the collectors didn't seem to have anything extra worth paying for.
October 12, 2013
I really liked this game
This is a large game and I admit I was happy that you could get from place to place via the map. Some games & puzzles were easier than others. There were a few that tested my patience. It is very well drawn and fun.
September 25, 2013
I am a seasoned player and I found this game quite detailed and involving. I enjoyed playing it. My only criticism is that the puzzles were not very original and I would like the option of playing a mini game instead of HO scenes.
August 26, 2013
Ok, the other games in this series were not as dark and creepy. I have to say if they keep heading in that direction I won't personally play another one. Graphics were great, the game was easy to follow, but too dark and creapy for me. It is hard for me to recommend a game I myself would not buy had I know it would be like that. However as far as story and game play it was right up there with some of the better games so I give it four stars for the quality the darkness can be removed and the game would still be fun to play. HOS's were different and I liked that, interactive to say the least. As far as challenging it had that. I leave this one up to the gamer to decide what they prefer.
August 20, 2013
good game but I'll wait for the SE
I have played all the Echoes games and have liked them. The graphics are good. The HOS are about the same as all of there games. Puzzles are good. I will wait for the SE. Not that much for achievements for me.
August 16, 2013
No Despair Here
This was a fun game. It kept me interested as well as busy and the HO's had a nice little twist to them. Really like this game.
Graphics were very well done and music was soothing. Going on my must buy list.
September 25, 2013
Back and forth like a rocking horse
The graphics were absolutely fantastic. One room can affect the progress of another. Overall, the game was rather busy, the flow of the movements choppy. The hint button worked well as a guide, although it did not actually direct you, it showed where you should go. I did not need to use the map. The one disconcerting thing that did bother me was the inventory at the top of the page instead of the bottom, where most games have it. Not a bad game, though.
September 1, 2013