Surface: The Pantheon Collector's Edition
Torn (based on demo)
I don't usually do reviews just on the demo, but I'm still torn as to whether to purchase this one or not, and I wanted to just say a few things. Having enjoyed the first two in the series, I really wanted to like this one too. Unfortunately, I found this one a little disappointing in comparison.
I thought the usually stunning Elephant graphics were somehow lacking their usual clarity and depth, and the cut scenes were really fuzzy. On the subject of cut scenes, I found there were way too many, practically every scene change, so that I felt as if I was watching more than playing.
I was also disappointed with the puzzles. As with the last Elephant game I demoed (and didn't buy), they seem to have become so easy, some ridiculously so. One just basically involved counting from 1-16, now where is the challenge in that?
I like the fact that they have kept the flowers to collect, which count towards earning different things in 'The Pantheon', and good to see the achievements still include earned things, rather than awards for simply progressing through the game.
I know Elephant games are on a 50% discount today, but for me, the jury is still out. I really hope this isn't the pattern of things to come from Elephant. Many others seem to be raving about this, so I guess you'll just have to try it for yourself. One thing I would say though, is try the first in the series before you try this one.
September 25, 2013
An OK game
It is a well done and easy game but not much fun for me. too much junk and building sites and laboratories. I guess younger players would enjoy it more. I am 60 and like games that draw me in completely with more challeneges and a bit of reality.
September 22, 2013
A movie or a game?
Music is good; graphics are excellent; plot's a little silly but so are most of the games if you think about it. That said, I didn't like the game. Voices used in voice overs were good but I felt like I spent more time watching cut scenes and listening to heroine anguish through her emotional turmoil that it became quite boring. Stuck to the end, but didn't even bother to play the bonus game. Maybe some day. Loved the other surface games, especially #1 in the series but this had WAY too much talking and coaching. Puzzles (few and far between) were simple. HO's were interactive but also few and far between. Mostly going around, picking up stuff, reusing it relatively soon and then watching another movie. Sorry, but three stars is generous. Won't be replaying it soon (and I've replayed #1 and #2 several times.
September 27, 2013
The previous Surface games were good; this one is barely OK. The story line is interesting, but it is so poorly told that one just wishes it was over. Which it is with a big bang making no sense at all - terrible ending. The bonus chapter is just as bad. The journal is the bare minimum and useless.
Game play is average. I hate the way these developers use inventory items in the HOS. The HINT button tells one exactly what to do, another bad idea. There is a good jump map showing areas needing action.
The artwork is good, and live actors are used. Too bad they usually just stand there like dummies. Their lips don't move for the VOs.
As in the other Surface game, the collectibles are flowers - no new thinking here. Get enough of them and you can go to some room for "extra" fun. Ho, hum. The other "extras" are the same old wallpapers, etc. Double ho, hum.
I don't recommend spending the extra for the CE for sure. This is not a very good game. Maybe the SE.
October 9, 2013
this game is not something that you can follow by logic. very disjointed and way too much dialog you just watch. i finally started skipping it because you watch more than you play.
October 3, 2013
That item is used for what??
Meh. It was okay. The beginning clip of this game is what got me interested. It was so well done. Throughout the game; however, I became frustrated in how items were being used. Some just don't make any sense. The games were pretty good and challenging. Just couldn't get too excited about any of it really. I would say that this isn't one of Elephant's best games.
October 1, 2013
is this a movie?
I bought this game without playing the free trial. I would be a great game, but there are so many cut scenes that I'm not sure whether I'm playing a game or watching a movie.
September 24, 2013
Much less intutive then the other surface games
I have all the other suface games and looked forward to playing this one. I found that this game made me much more frustrated then any of the others, sometimes solutions were just totally out of line, for example, who would think of cutting open upolstry with a potato peeler, I don't know about anyone else but my potato peeler would in no way cut open a heavy cloth as in on seats in a train. This is but one example of items that were perfectly logical to use from your inventory but not acceptable and the really bazar item being the one to use. I ended up using the help button way more then any other games I enjoyed the graphics, voice over was quite good, although many times not quite synced to what was happening.
September 27, 2013
Not the Best
I read other reviews that commended the game and bought it....boy was I mistaken...This game was one big un-fun running in circles to get items and solve things---too MUCH....AND if you like the characters talking ALL the time, this is a good one for you (although they talk about nothing of significance in my opionion).....Personally I felt the game was geared toward the Grade school level.....Also, not enough Hidden Object games to my liking...But, whatever floats your boat.
September 23, 2013
Not so much for me
Although the reviews were good, I was so disengaged that I didn't even pay attention. It was over before I knew it, and just felt "meh." I wouldn't buy it again. I am not even sure I am going to play the bonus content.
September 28, 2013