Nancy Drew: Ghost Dogs of Moon Lake
Vast Improvement over Scarlet Hand
Both "Secret of the Scarlet Hand" and "Ghost Dogs of Moon Lake" have been published in 2002. The first one in September, the other one in November. But during those months there must have been some kind of meeting at the developer that I am not allowed to name.
I criticized "Scarlet Hand" for having an ancient graphic, not much interaction with other characters and my biggest beef was that you had to travel back to the hotel all the time to look at your notes, thus having to write down everything and draw maps for yourself.
Now, what did they change in Moon Lake, Pennsylvania? Interaction is still at a minimum, you meet three people during the game. Graphics seem to be a little better, let's say instead of 1992 I would now say you can compare it to games from 1999. :-) But, big BUT, you get a Palm. So essentially you have your clues with you all the time - get stuck, have a look on the palm, you are on your way again. And suddenly the game is much less unnerving and much better.
The puzzles are fine, most of the time it's clear what you have to do - and you can always phone Bess, George and the Hardys, with the phone being in a convenient, central location. Scare factor is minimal though - you see the dogs once at the start of the game, then nothing until the showdown. When you find the culprit's diary it's also easy to figure out whose face will appear in the tunnel.
Bottom Line: Big improvement over the previous game, recommended as entry to the series.
December 17, 2011
I loved ghost dogs of moon lake and although I got confused a lot XD it was still really fun and was my favourite. This game had a lot of puzzles and although many were hard, I lived to see the haunted carousel, and I am happy to say that this game was awesome!!!
December 29, 2011
A Fantastic Game
Either I suddenly became better at figuring out how Nancy Drew games work, or what you have to do is alot more clear in Ghost Dogs over other Nancy Drew games. Although at the very beginning I found myself wandering around not sure what to do, after I did the instigating tasks what came next became quite easy to figure out. Not to the extent where the plot's predictable, but of course. I had begun to think that wandering around aimlessly was a necessary part of Nancy Drew games. Fortunately, Ghost Dogs proved me wrong. I sigh in relief.
This is one of the Nancy Drew games without much of a theme, which has its good points aswell as bad. Basically, if you hate mythology, you do not have to worry about hating the game because of the reliance on mythology, but the game tends to be weakened in intensity because of this lack of a focal point for all the puzzles to revolve around.
On the topic of puzzles, there is more of an adventure theme to this game than puzzles. Not that it is bare of puzzles, but they are more directly relevant to the game than they are minigames. In my opinion this is a good thing because the "puzzles" in the latest Nancy Drews bare a most peculiar resemblance to fillers.
Basically, this is not the most engrossing Nancy Drew there is, but it is excellent. It has no sub plots, and is not of epic length. #Although some adventure games are# If you were lying in bed thinking about this game, it would be more of a "Hmm, that game is really interesting. I wonder what happens next?" instead of a "What just happened there was awesome! How did they even think of that? What do I do next? What happens next? Oh, who cares about sleep! I need to know who did it!" It's enjoyable and makes you look at things a different way #like all Nancy Drew games#, but it is not something with so much atmosphere you cannot stop having dreams about it. Is it the best game ever? No. Is it a fantastic game? Absolutely.
April 15, 2012
It was an OK game
Only one of a few nancy drew games I have played (apart from the dossier series). I play loads of other straight adventure games.
The good - graphics, feeling you are on an adventure, and the maze (the first time!)
not so good - I had to keep going back and forth for conversations with people after I did something and this took a lot of time and most of it, nothing new to say - so infuriating.
If you don't like mazes this game isn't for you. I had to keep going back through this out door maze and just kept getting lost. It was very well done but at the end could have thrown the whole game out the window when I had to keep going through it! There is sort of an other maze as well, indoor.
I don't like walkthroughs so spent ages wandering around not knowing what to do next, loads of backtracking and the maze brought down the game for me. (usually in adventure games the objectives are clearer and you know what and when to do something)
If you like mazes I recommend it. I discovered through this game that I don't!
Puzzles were nice when you got to them.
January 5, 2012
Spooky who dunnit (or rather... whose doin it) :)
An excellent Nancy Drew game that takes you away from the mainstream stress of everyday life into a little cottage/cabin in the quiet, tranquil woods owned by a friend of the family who recently purchased it... or IS it all that??
If you want to call it a vacation?! Afterall you will have no access to a car to get away in, only a motor boat to travel with the option of travel by foot to escape in a large expanse of wilderness and in addition, you will have to be concerned about having all the supplies you need, and whether the water may be tainted, AND there is a chance you will be killed, or frightened to death... but, through it all, hey, remember.... you can do it and it's a paid vacation, afterall!!!
So... just exactly WHO or WHAT is behind all the terrorizing and exactly who or what can you trust in your immediate vacinity OR even those from the past during your stay?!!
Will YOU be able to find out while unraveling this mystery and will you be surprised as to just who/what ends up to be the culprit.... or will you be KILLED!!??? YOU will have to play to find out !!!!...... Bwaahaahaaa.
January 11, 2012
This is a classic ND game and one of its best. The setting is creepy. I first played it back in college, the CD has broken since then, and luckily BFG sells this and I quickly bought it. I love the storyline, and the dogs are actually pretty cute! If you're a mystery fan, whether or not you like Nancy Drew, you should give this game a try.
July 14, 2012
I really love Nancy Drew games, and it truly was a mystery to me! I kept changing my mind about who did it. The game itself wasn't scary for me at all, yet I still had nightmares, but the game isn't frightening unless you count the dogs at night which were startling for me.
November 17, 2012
What a Nice Surprise! Loved This Game!!!!
This is the 7th game in the series, the first game I ever played was Alibi In Ashes and I was hooked! Since then I've played some newer but decided to go back and play the older games from #3 up in no particular order!
Having just finished Ghost Dogs I'd give it 10 stars if I could!
Excellent storyline that flows perfectly!!
I assumed it would be easy.. Oh no.. It?s as difficult or more than some of the newer games and as fun as some of the best! But very seldom do you need any help as in a walkthrough! Nancy does have a PDA in this game which comes in handy!
Nancy goes to visit a friend Sally McDonald who bought a run down cabin on Moon Lake in Pennsylvania. Once owned by the infamous gangster-Mickey Malone- in the 1920?s!
But, as with all ND games when she arrives nothing is as it should be.. Is it ever???
Upon arrival Nancy finds out Sally is gone and left a note that she couldn't stay another night! The phone rings it?s Sally, the conversation is broken up but she begs Nancy to leave, just get out of there, the Dogs, the Dogs!! Well, that only makes our young detective more curious and determined to stay and find out who or what ran Sally off her property! Plus a tree fell behind Nancy?s car when she arrived so she can?t leave.. Convenient huh?
Dogs with glowing eyes and teeth attacking and rattling the house at night would scare me off too, but not Miss Drew!
Of the older games this one is long and you do a lot of running around, it adds length to the game of course but It didn?t take away from the game..
The Map for the forest is difficult to navigate and you go in the forest very often so be prepared to get lost! Luckily the forest has some landmarks so you can get your bearings! I did get lost so long twice it changed from day to night and sent me back to the cabin!
You need to go into the forest so much I just started to have the turns figured out around the time the game ended.. Ha!
Besides the forest you take a motor boat (you have to fix# to Em?s emporium #the store# and The Ranger Station!
There are 3 characters you interact with
Red Knott-The Bird Watcher.. Very enjoyable character!
Emily--Owner of Em?s Emporium
Jeff Akers--AKA Park Ranger Akers
Phone Interactions include:
The Hardy Boys
Bess and George
Vivian Whitmore - Mickey?s former girlfriend, she?s still alive and knows a lot about Malone's house and it?s secrets.
All ND games are geared towards sleuthing, solving the mystery, puzzles and learning new things!
I enjoyed the things you learn in this game.. To name a few:
Real history about Malone via newspaper clippings from the 1920?s..
Different kinds of bird sounds and photographing them..
Bug catching I could have done without but it?s quick and easy!
Since you apparently arrived without a dime to your name which I find silly as wealthy as Nancy?s Dad is that he would let Nancy go broke and all? So you have to work #do puzzles) for anything you need from Em?s and the Ranger.
Read all the literature at the Ranger Station it?s very helpful in real life situations..
There is one difficult timed puzzle that gets you killed a time or two before you figure it out!
And another towards the end..
The need for Second Chances are plentiful throughout this game too..
This is just an over-all fun game with everything you expect from Nancy Drew.. Including ?Things that go bump in the night??
With most games I would call myself intermediate.. Nancy Drew games I'm still a beginner!
Enjoy your stay at Moon Lake and beware of the Ghost Dogs!!
April 30, 2013
what a piece of garbage!!
the worst to navigate story I've ever tried.
The worst Nancy Drew I've ever tried.
For free this wouldn't be worth it.
March 14, 2013
super fun and challenging
and a great story line to ( =
June 1, 2013