Nancy Drew: The Haunting of Castle Malloy
War meets Medieval
When I first see the preview of this game, I was excited. I thought this will be similar to Curse of Blackmoor Manor, ND visiting old castle in Ireland, and it all started so well, with reported banshee, but then I kind of like 'what?' when 'World War II' came to conversation. It's not good to combine both as it is like scientific meets local legend, it doesnt mix. Everything from graphic to sound is great in this game, but the storyline as it progressed doesn't make much sense. Sorry, HER Interactive, the Blackmoor Manor is wayyy better than this one.
June 29, 2012
Enjoyable atmosphere, just not enough content.
Ive been playing all the ND games in order of release. Like almost all ND games, this one suffered from horrific interior navigation controls, but once you got outside it was much better. Yet again, this was a typical ND game with regards to the necessity for loads of note taking. Have a notepad and pen with you, because you will need it.
Fun Factor: In actuality, it was overall boring. With only a few places you could travel to, a ridiculous storyline, and not very likeable characters.. well.. you were somewhat challenged to enjoy the game. Some of the mini-puzzles were lots of fun tho. The atmosphere was rather immersive, and probably what saves this game.
Visual/Sound: graphics were decent, animation was .. a little on the rough side, sound was .. O.K. but not impressive. The major ding in the game was how limited the space was. I noticed no bathroom visits were included in this one.. were they using an outhouse???
Level of challenge: The variety of challenges/puzzles was decent, and in fact I enjoyed the nice mixture of them. Most weren't difficult to solve but there were a couple that were a tad over the top which can kill the fun. Overall enjoyable, but you may need help with one or two of them. Warning.. the swamp notes you get .. just throw them out.. it really just comes down to trial and error which way to hop.
Storyline.. oh gads. Not believable, very weak, in fact, this is one of the very few ND games that really completely failed in this department. At least others with weak stories, had some secondary support system like history or something to fluff it all up.. but not this one. Just.. fell flat on it's face. So sad.
I enjoyed the game, good play length, but occasionally ridiculous challenges and very limited interaction. I guess I would recommend this game to intermediate or advance level players, but definitely not for novices.
December 18, 2013
Moving about in the game was very frustrating - I kept moving in circles within the castle; eventually, without any particular reason, I got to where the next sequence of events would occur. Within outdoor scenes, the entire thing was in the dark and it was more miss than hit to get where you needed to go. Help information was useless.
I was a big fan of the Nancy Drew books and thought I'd enjoy the story line in game format - never again will I order one of these nor any other game by this creator.
July 29, 2013
Only for the die-hard Drewers
An incredibly tricky chemical puzzle near the end of the game
destroys (no pun intended) all enjoyment and especially after getting through trying to guess the temperment of a bunch of sheep and not to mention an awful druming game.
This game is only for die-hard Nancy Drew fans and good luck to them.
March 28, 2012
This is the worst game I have played since joining BF, and I've played a LOT of games. No direction on how to play/solve the puzzles, bad graphics, dialogue took forever to get through.
I'm not even going to finish this game...The reason I play is to relax, not to get frustrated.
August 21, 2013
first time playing games of N. Drew and last, got stack freom the beggining, no hints no explanation of nothing,no my type of game
didn't like it
don't buy it likely cost only $4
January 28, 2013